If you love a good mystery without the gore, dark drama, or nightmare-inducing plot twists, then cozy mystery TV shows are for you! These shows are the perfect mix of intrigue, warmth, and community. They’re like a big mug of tea with a splash of crime-solving on the side—safe, satisfying, and often sprinkled with humour (or even a little magic). Whether you’re new to the genre or looking for more to binge, here are the best cozy mystery TV shows guaranteed to make you feel good while still keeping you guessing.
What Is a Cozy Mystery?
A cozy mystery is a subgenre of crime drama that avoids graphic violence and gritty realism. Instead, expect:
✔ Amateur detectives (writers, bakers, gardeners—ordinary people with extraordinary curiosity).
✔ Picturesque settings, from quaint villages to historic cities.
✔ Lighthearted tone, often with a dash of humour or romance.
✔ Satisfying endings—the bad guy always gets caught.
If you enjoy charming stories that feel like a warm hug, you’re in the right place.
Top 12 Cozy Mystery TV Shows to Watch Now
1. Murder, She Wrote
Why You’ll Love It: Angela Lansbury as Jessica Fletcher is an icon of the genre. A mystery writer who solves murders in small-town America (and beyond), she’s smart, warm, and utterly loveable.
Streaming: Peacock, Amazon Prime.
2. Nancy Drew
Why You’ll Love It: A modern spin on the beloved classic with a darker, spookier twist and supernatural elements. Nancy is clever, brave, and impossible not to root for.
Streaming: HBO Max, Prime Video (region-dependent).
3. Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries
Why You’ll Love It: Set in the roaring 1920s, this series is pure glamour. Watch it for the clever plots, but stay for Phryne Fisher’s stunning clothes and fearless attitude.
Streaming: Acorn TV, PBS Masterpiece.
4. My Life is Murder
Why You’ll Love It: Lucy Lawless (yes, Xena!) brings charisma and wit to Alexa Crowe, a former detective drawn back into crime-solving. Gorgeous Australian and New Zealand backdrops included.
Streaming: Acorn TV, Prime Video.
5. Grantchester
Why You’ll Love It: A charming vicar and a no-nonsense detective team up to solve crimes in an idyllic English village. Heartfelt and beautifully filmed.
Streaming: PBS Masterpiece, ITV, Prime Video.
6. Agatha Raisin
Why You’ll Love It: A sassy PR exec moves to a quiet village and ends up solving murders. Quirky characters, bold fashion, and Cotswolds scenery make this one irresistible.
Streaming: Acorn TV, Prime Video.
7. Rosemary & Thyme
Why You’ll Love It: Two gardening enthusiasts stumble across crimes while restoring gardens across Europe. Cozy, gentle, and packed with scenic beauty.
Streaming: BritBox, Prime Video.
8. Miss Scarlet and The Duke
Why You’ll Love It: A fiercely independent Victorian woman becomes a private detective, clashing and flirting with Scotland Yard’s Duke along the way.
Streaming: PBS Masterpiece, Prime Video.
9. Good Witch
Why You’ll Love It: If you prefer your mysteries with a sprinkle of magic, this Hallmark gem blends small-town warmth with a touch of enchantment.
Streaming: Hallmark TV, Netflix (in some regions), Prime Video.
10. The Ghost Whisperer
Why You’ll Love It: Jennifer Love Hewitt helps spirits with unfinished business. Heartfelt stories, spooky twists, and plenty of emotional depth.
Streaming: Hulu, Prime Video.
11. Hallmark Mysteries
Hallmark’s mystery movie franchises are the ultimate in cozy, bingeable fun. Yes I know they’re actually movies but because they’re series, I figured I’d include them! My personal favourites:
- Aurora Teagarden Mysteries – Librarian by day, sleuth by night. Prime Video.
- Hannah Swensen Mysteries – Baking + murder (don’t worry, it’s still cosy!). Prime Video.
- Garage Sale Mysteries – Antique hunting meets amateur detective work. Prime Video.
- There are numerous other cozy mystery movie series on the Hallmark channel that you can watch live or stream that are equally as entertaining! The Crossword Mysteries, The Jane Mysteries, Curious Caterer Mysteries, The Cases of Mystery Lane, Nelly Knows MysteriesGilded Newport Mysteries, etc.
Streaming: Hallmark Movies & Mysteries.
12. Professor T
Why You’ll Love It: A brilliant but eccentric criminology professor helps police crack cases while navigating his own quirks (and boy is he quirky lol). Offbeat and engaging.
Streaming: PBS Masterpiece, Prime Video, BBCiPlayer.
Bonus: Father Brown
Why You’ll Love It: Based on G.K. Chesterton’s stories, Father Brown is a Catholic priest with a sharp mind for solving crimes. Old-school charm in the Cotswolds.
Streaming: Prime Video, BritBox, BBCiPlayer.
Final Thoughts
Cozy mystery TV shows are comfort viewing at its best. I can’t get enough of them! They deliver intrigue without the nightmares, quirky characters you’ll love, and a sense of community that makes you want to move into those picture-perfect towns (murders aside lol!).
I’m also a big fan of cozy mystery books (preferably with fantasy elements!) but we’ll talk about that in a future post! Have I missed any of your favourites? Tell me in the comments—I’m always looking for my next binge-worthy cozy mystery!
